Rewrite OpenXR hand tracking to reflect new architecture

tutorials/xr/index.rst

@@ -31,6 +31,7 @@ Advanced topics
    xr_room_scale
    openxr_composition_layers
    openxr_hand_tracking
+   openxr_body_tracking
 
 Godot XR Tools
 --------------

tutorials/xr/openxr_body_tracking.rst

@@ -0,0 +1,38 @@
+.. _doc_openxr_body_tracking:
+
+OpenXR body tracking
+====================
+
+Support for full body tracking in OpenXR is only just becoming available for a select few platforms.
+As support solidifies information will be added to this page.
+
+HTC Tracker support
+-------------------
+
+An option that has been available for some time is doing full body tracking using HTC trackers.
+These are currently supported through SteamVR and on HTC Elite XR headsets.
+They are exposed through the action map system.
+
+These trackers are identified by their roles which are assigned to them when configured.
+Simply add :ref:`XRController3D <class_xrcontroller3d>` nodes as children to
+the :ref:`XROrigin3D <class_xrorigin3d>` node and assign one of the following trackers:
+
+.. list-table:: HTC trackers
+  :widths: 100
+  :header-rows: 0
+
+  * - /user/vive_tracker_htcx/role/handheld_object
+  * - /user/vive_tracker_htcx/role/left_foot
+  * - /user/vive_tracker_htcx/role/right_foot
+  * - /user/vive_tracker_htcx/role/left_shoulder
+  * - /user/vive_tracker_htcx/role/right_shoulder
+  * - /user/vive_tracker_htcx/role/left_elbow
+  * - /user/vive_tracker_htcx/role/right_elbow
+  * - /user/vive_tracker_htcx/role/left_knee
+  * - /user/vive_tracker_htcx/role/right_knee
+  * - /user/vive_tracker_htcx/role/waist
+  * - /user/vive_tracker_htcx/role/chest
+  * - /user/vive_tracker_htcx/role/camera
+  * - /user/vive_tracker_htcx/role/keyboard
+
+You can now use these as targets for IK modifiers on a full body avatar.

tutorials/xr/openxr_hand_tracking.rst

@@ -1,201 +1,355 @@
 .. _doc_openxr_hand_tracking:
 
-The OpenXR hand tracking
-========================
-
-Hand tracking is the process by which the position and orientation of the players hands are tracked,
-including the orientation of the players fingers.
-We can identify 3 categories of this:
-
-One, hand tracking through external sensors such as cameras.
-This is what Hololens, Quest, UltraLeap and similar devices do.
-This often results in very accurate tracking of all fingers of the players hands.
-
-Two, hand tracking through VR gloves.
-This method is still mostly experimental but is likely to gain popularity soon.
-Gloves often have good finger tracking capabilities but their real selling point is the ability to restrict movement.
-This allows the sensation of touch.
-Gloves are often also recognised as controllers and often will have additional controls such as buttons embedded.
-
-Three, inferred hand tracking.
-This has been the de facto approach since the early days of VR.
-As we know the player is holding a controller and we know the position of this controller,
-we can infer where to render the players hand.
-Fingers can be positioned based on the controls the player is interacting with.
-Many modern VR controllers have additional sensors to help determine finger positions on the controller.
+OpenXR hand tracking
+====================
+
+Introduction
+------------
 
 .. note::
 
-  Traditionally inferred hand tracking has been the responsibility of the game.
-  However the principles behind the action map have somewhat limited the viable options here.
-  Valve is currently the only XR Runtime that has implemented inferred hand tracking as part of the hand tracking extension.
-  There is an expectation that other XR Runtimes will follow this example in the near future.
-
-  Until then we recommend that if your game depends on inferred hand tracking,
-  to use the hand assets that are part of Godot XR Tools.
-
-Tracking through interaction profiles
--------------------------------------
-
-Tracking the location and state of controllers are performed through interaction profiles.
-Bindings can be set within the :ref:`action map <doc_xr_action_map>`.
-
-However it is important to realise that in OpenXR controllers are bound to paths indicating the usage of these controllers.
-I.e. the controller held in the players left hand is bound to ``/user/hand/left``
-while the controller in the players right hand is bound to ``/user/hand/right``.
-And while not yet supported outside of the HTC tracker extension,
-it is likely OpenXR will be extended with paths such as ``/user/foot/left`` and ``/user/foot/right`` at some point.
-
-.. warning::
-
-  This paradigm therefore begs the question what happens to a controller that is not being held by a user.
-  There is no answer to this question yet, this is still being debated and the specification may change in the near future.
-  The behavior is thus undefined and can be different for different platforms.
-
-  The most common is that the controller will remain bound regardless of whether the player is actually holding the controller.
-
-  However there are runtimes, such as the Quest, that can unbind a controller when it is not being held by the user.
-
-  This may become the norm in the future and the expectation is that the action map system will be enhanced accordingly.
-
-The hand tracking extension
----------------------------
-
-OpenXR has an extension that exposes hand tracking functionality.
-This extension allows a game to request the hand skeleton with all bone positions for each hand.
-
-.. figure:: img/openxr_hand_skeleton.webp
-  :align: center
-
-  Copyright (c) 2017-2022, The Khronos Group Inc. SPDX-License-Identifier: CC-BY-4.0
-
-The above image shows the joints that have to be provided by each XR runtime that implements this extension.
-
-Currently Godot exposes this functionality through the :ref:`OpenXRHand <class_openxrhand>` node.
-This is a helper node that will retrieve the hand tracking data from OpenXR and apply it to a skeleton in Godot.
-You select either the left or right hand through the ``hand`` property on this node.
-
-The hand asset itself has to be provided by the developer and is thus separate from the OpenXRHand node.
-You set the ``hand_skeleton`` on the OpenXRHand node to the skeleton it needs to apply the tracking data to.
-
-If supported by the XR runtime you can also set the ``motion_range`` property to limit how far the hand can close.
-
-The skeleton for this asset has to have the following bones:
-
-.. list-table:: OpenXR hand skeleton
-  :widths: 50 50
-  :header-rows: 1
-
-  * - Left hand
-    - Right hand
-  * - Palm_L
-    - Palm_R
-  * - Wrist_L
-    - Wrist_R
-  * - Thumb_Metacarpal_L
-    - Thumb_Metacarpal_R
-  * - Thumb_Proximal_L
-    - Thumb_Proximal_R
-  * - Thumb_Distal_L
-    - Thumb_Distal_R
-  * - Thumb_Tip_L
-    - Thumb_Tip_R
-  * - Index_Metacarpal_L
-    - Index_Metacarpal_R
-  * - Index_Proximal_L
-    - Index_Proximal_R
-  * - Index_Intermediate_L
-    - Index_Intermediate_R
-  * - Index_Distal_L
-    - Index_Distal_R
-  * - Index_Tip_L
-    - Index_Tip_R
-  * - Middle_Metacarpal_L
-    - Middle_Metacarpal_R
-  * - Middle_Proximal_L
-    - Middle_Proximal_R
-  * - Middle_Intermediate_L
-    - Middle_Intermediate_R
-  * - Middle_Distal_L
-    - Middle_Distal_R
-  * - Middle_Tip_L
-    - Middle_Tip_R
-  * - Ring_Metacarpal_L
-    - Ring_Metacarpal_R
-  * - Ring_Proximal_L
-    - Ring_Proximal_R
-  * - Ring_Intermediate_L
-    - Ring_Intermediate_R
-  * - Ring_Distal_L
-    - Ring_Distal_R
-  * - Ring_Tip_L
-    - Ring_Tip_R
-  * - Little_Metacarpal_L
-    - Little_Metacarpal_R
-  * - Little_Proximal_L
-    - Little_Proximal_R
-  * - Little_Intermediate_L
-    - Little_Intermediate_R
-  * - Little_Distal_L
-    - Little_Distal_R
-  * - Little_Tip_L
-    - Little_Tip_R
-
-.. warning::
-
-  The skeleton data returned from different XR runtimes are often not compatible which poses a problem for cross platform development.
-
-  For instance both Microsoft and Meta runtimes base the skeleton on the actual hands of the player.
-  These skeletons will thus conform to the size of the players hand.
-
-  Contrast that to Valve where a fixed skeleton is used if inferred hand tracking is applied.
-
-  We are still gathering experience on how best to deal with these differences in the platforms.
-
-When exporting to Meta Quest you need to enable the following setting:
+    This page focuses specifically on the feature set exposed through OpenXR.
+    Parts of the functionality presented here also applies to WebXR and can by provided
+    by other XR interfaces.
+
+When discussing hand tracking it is important to know that there are differences of opinion as to where lines are drawn.
+The practical result of this is that there are differences in implementation between the different OpenXR runtimes.
+You may find yourself in a place where chosen hardware doesn't support a piece of the puzzle or does things differently
+enough from the other platforms that you need to do extra work.
+
+That said, recent improvements to the OpenXR specification are closing these gaps and as platforms implement
+these improvements we are getting closer to a future where we have either full portability between platforms
+or at least a clear way to detect the capabilities of a platform.
+
+When we look at the early days of VR the focus of the major platforms was on tracked controller based input.
+Here we are tracking a physical device that also has buttons for further input.
+From the tracking data we can infer the location of the player's hands but no further information is known,
+traditionally it was left up to the game to implement a mechanism to display the player's hand and animate
+the fingers based on further input from the controller, be it due to buttons being pressed or through proximity
+sensors.
+Often fingers are also placed based on context, what the user is holding, and what action a user is performing.
+
+More recently optical hand tracking has become a popular solution, where cameras track the user's hands
+and full tracking data for the hand and finger positions becomes available.
+Many vendors saw this as completely separate from controller tracking and introduced independent APIs to
+access hand and finger positions and orientation data.
+When handling input, it was up to the game developer to implement a gesture detection mechanism.
+
+This split also exists in OpenXR, where controller tracking is handled primarily by the action map system,
+while optical hand tracking is primarily handled by the hand tracking API extension.
+
+However, the world is not that black and white and we're seeing a number of scenarios
+where we cross the line:
+
+ *  Devices that fit in both categories, such as tracked gloves
+    and controllers such as the Index controller that also perform finger tracking.
+ *  XR Runtimes that implement inferred hand tracking from controller data as a means
+    to solve proper finger placement for multiple controllers.
+ *  XR applications that wish to seamlessly switch between controller and hand tracking
+    offering the same user experience regardless of approach used.
+
+OpenXR is answering this call by introducing further extensions that lets us query the capabilities of
+the XR runtime/hardware or that add further functionality across this divide.
+The problem that currently does remain is that there are gaps in adopting these extensions,
+with some platforms thus not reporting capabilities to their full extent.
+As such you may need to test for the features available on specific hardware
+and adjust your approach accordingly.
+
+Demo project
+------------
+
+The information presented on this page was used to create a demo project that can be found
+`here <https://github.com/godotengine/godot-demo-projects/tree/master/xr/openxr_hand_tracking_demo>`_.
+
+
+The Hand Tracking API
+---------------------
+
+As mentioned in our introduction, the hand tracking API is primarily used with optical hand tracking
+and on many platforms only works when the user is not holding a controller.
+Some platforms support controller inferred hand tracking meaning that you will get hand tracking data
+even if the user is holding a controller.
+This includes SteamVR, Meta Quest (currently native only but Meta link support is likely coming),
+and hopefully soon others as well.
+
+The hand tracking implementation in Godot has been standardized around the Godot Humanoid Skeleton
+and works both in OpenXR and WebXR. The instructions below will thus work in both environments.
+
+In order to use the hand tracking API with OpenXR you first need to enable it.
+This can be done in the project settings:
 
 .. image:: img/xr_enable_handtracking.webp
 
-Body tracking
--------------
+For some standalone XR devices you also need to configure the hand tracking extension in export settings,
+for instance for Meta Quest:
+
+.. image:: img/openxr_enable_hand_tracking_meta.webp
+
+Now you need to add 3 components into your scene for each hand:
+
+ *  A tracked node to position the hand.
+ *  A properly skinned hand mesh with skeleton.
+ *  A skeleton modifier that applies finger tracking data to the skeleton.
+
+.. image:: img/openxr_hand_tracking_nodes.webp
+
+Hand tracking node
+^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
+
+The hand tracking system uses separate hand trackers to track the position of the player's hands
+within our tracking space. 
+
+This information has been separated out for the following use cases:
+
+ *  Tracking happens in the local space of the :ref:`XROrigin3D <class_xrorigin3d>` node.
+    This node must be a child of the `XROrigin3D` node in order to be correctly placed.
+ *  This node can be used as an IK target when an upper body mesh with arms is used instead
+    of separate hand meshes.
+ *  Actual placement of the hands may be loosely bound to the tracking in scenarios such as
+    avatar creation UIs, fake mirrors, or similar situations
+    resulting in the hand mesh and finger tracking being localized elsewhere.
+
+We'll concentrate on the first use case only.
+
+For this you need to add an :ref:`XRNode3D <class_xrnode3d>` node to your ``XROrigin3D`` node.
+
+ *  On this node the ``tracker`` should be set to ``/user/hand_tracker/left`` or ``/user/hand_tracker/right``
+    for the left or right hand respectively.
+ *  The ``pose`` should remain set to ``default``, no other option will work here.
+ *  The checkbox ``Show When Tracked`` will automatically hide this node if no tracking data is available,
+    or make this node visible if tracking data is available. 
+
+Rigged hand mesh
+^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
+
+In order to display our hand we need a hand mesh that is properly rigged and skinned.
+For this Godot uses the hand bone structure as defined for the :ref:`Godot Humanoid <class_skeletonprofilehumanoid>`
+but optionally supporting an extra tip bone for each finger.
+
+The `OpenXR hand tracking demo <https://github.com/godotengine/godot-demo-projects/tree/master/xr/openxr_hand_tracking_demo>`_
+contains example GLTF files of properly rigged hands.
+
+We will be using those here and add them as a child to our ``XRNode3D`` node.
+We also need to enable editable children to gain access to our :ref:`Skeleton3D <class_skeleton3d>` node.
+
+The hand skeleton modifier
+^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
+
+Finally we need to add a :ref:`XRHandModifier3D <class_xrhandmodifier3d>` node as a child to our ``Skeleton3D`` node.
+This node will obtain the finger tracking data from OpenXR and apply it the hand model.
+
+You need to set the ``Hand Tracker`` property to either ``/user/hand_tracker/left`` or ``/user/hand_tracker/right``
+depending on whether we are apply the tracking data of respectively the left or right hand.
+
+You can also set the ``Bone Update`` mode on this node.
+
+ *  ``Full`` applies the hand tracking data fully.
+    This does mean that the skeleton positioning will potentially reflect the size of the actual hand of the user.
+    This can lead to scrunching effect if meshes aren't weighted properly to account for this.
+    Make sure you test your game with players of all sizes when optical hand tracking is used!
+ *  ``Rotation Only`` will only apply rotation to the bones of the hands and keep the bone length as is.
+    In this mode the size of the hand mesh doesn't change.
+
+With this added, when we run the project we should see the hand correctly displayed if hand tracking is supported. 
+
+The hand tracking data source
+-----------------------------
+
+This is an OpenXR extension that provides information about the source of the hand tracking data.
+At this moment only a few runtimes implement it but if it is available, Godot will activate it.
+
+If this extension is not supported and thus unknown is returned, you can make the following assumptions:
+
+ *  If you are using SteamVR (including Steam link), only controller based hand tracking is supported.
+ *  For any other runtime, if hand tracking is supported, only optical hand tracking is supported
+    (Note, Meta Link currently fall into this category).
+ *  In all other cases, no hand tracking is supported at all.
+
+You can access this information through code:
 
-At the time of writing, OpenXR does not support body tracking as part of the core spec.
-We are expecting this to change in the near future as more and more body tracking solutions are hitting the market.
+.. code-block:: gdscript
 
-For now the only option available here is through HTC trackers.
-There is an extension that becomes available if HTC trackers are supported by the XR runtime.
-These are fully exposed through the action map system.
+    var hand_tracker : XRHandTracker = XRServer.get_tracker('/user/hand_tracker/left')
+    if hand_tracker:
+        if hand_tracker.has_tracking_data:
+            if hand_tracker.hand_tracking_source == XRHandTracker.HAND_TRACKING_SOURCE_UNKNOWN:
+                print("Hand tracking source unknown")
+            elif hand_tracker.hand_tracking_source == XRHandTracker.HAND_TRACKING_SOURCE_UNOBSTRUCTED:
+                print("Hand tracking source is optical hand tracking")
+            elif hand_tracker.hand_tracking_source == XRHandTracker.HAND_TRACKING_SOURCE_CONTROLLER:
+                print("Hand tracking data is inferred from controller data")
+            else:
+                print("Unknown hand tracking source ", hand_tracker.hand_tracking_source)
+        else:
+            print("Hand is currently not being tracked")
+    else:
+        print("No hand tracker registered")
 
-Godot has full support for these and you can setup the trackers in the action map.
-Each tracker is assigned a usage within the SteamVR interface.
+This example simply logs the state for the left hand.
+
+If in this example no hand tracker is returned by ``get_tracker``,
+this means the hand tracking API is not supported on the XR runtime at all.
+
+If there is a tracker but `has_tracking_data` is false, the user's hand is currently not being tracked.
+This is likely caused by one of the following reasons:
+
+ *  The player's hand is not visible by any of the tracking cameras on the headset
+ *  The player is currently using a controller and the headset only supports optical hand tracking
+ *  The controller is turned off and only controller hand tracking is supported.
+
+Handling user input
+-------------------
+
+Reacting to actions performed by the user is handled through :ref:`doc_xr_action_map`
+if controllers are used.
+In the action map you can map various inputs like the trigger or joystick on the controller
+to an action. This can then drive logic in your game.
+
+When hand tracking is used we originally had no such inputs,
+inputs are driven by gestures made by the user such as making a fist to grab
+or pinching the thumb and index finger together to select something.
+It was up to the game developer to implement this.
+
+Recognizing that there is an increasing demand for applications that can switch seamlessly
+between controller and hand tracking and the need some form of basic input capability,
+a number of extensions were added to the specification that provide some basic gesture recognition
+and can be used with the action map.
+
+The hand interaction profile
+^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
+
+The `hand interaction profile extension <https://github.khronos.org/OpenXR-Inventory/extension_support.html#XR_EXT_hand_interaction>`_
+is a new core extension which supports pinch, grasp, and poke gestures and related poses.
+There is still limited support for this extension but it should become available in more
+runtimes in the near future.
+
+.. image:: img/openxr_hand_interaction_profile.webp
+
+The pinch gesture is triggered by pinching your thumb and index finger together.
+This is often used as a select gesture for menu systems, similar to using your controller
+to point at an object and press the trigger to select and is thus often mapped as such.
+
+ *  The ``pinch pose`` is a pose positioned in the middle between the tip of the thumb and
+    the tip of the index finger and oriented such that a ray cast can be used to identify a target.
+ *  The ``pinch`` float input is a value between 0.0 (the tip of the thumb and index finger are apart)
+    and 1.0 (the tip of the thumb and index finger are touching).
+ *  The ``pinch ready`` input is true when the tips of the fingers are (close to) touching.
+
+The grasp gesture is triggered by making a fist and is often used to pick items up,
+similar to engaging the squeeze input on controllers.
+
+ *  The ``grasp`` float input is a value between 0.0 (open hand) and 1.0 (fist).
+ *  The ``grasp ready`` input is true when the user made a fist.
+
+The poke gesture is triggered by extending your index finger, this one is a bit
+of an exception as the pose at the tip of your index finger is often used to poke
+an interactable object. The ``poke pose`` is a pose positioned on the tip of the index finger.
+
+Finally the ``aim activate (ready)`` input is defined as an input that is 1.0/true
+when the index finger is extended and pointing at a target that can be activated.
+How runtimes interpret this, is not clear.
+
+With this setup the normal ``left_hand`` and ``right_hand`` trackers are used and you can
+thus seamlessly switch between controller and hand tracking input.
+
+.. note::
+
+    You need to enable the hand interaction profile extension in the OpenXR project settings.
+
+Microsoft hand interaction profile
+^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
+
+The `Microsoft hand interaction profile extension <https://github.khronos.org/OpenXR-Inventory/extension_support.html#XR_MSFT_hand_interaction>`_
+was introduced by Microsoft and loosely mimics the simple controller profile.
+Meta has also added support for this extension but only on their native OpenXR client,
+it is currently not available over Meta Link.
+
+.. image:: img/openxr_msft_hand_interaction_profile.webp
+
+Pinch support is exposed through the ``select`` input, the value of which
+is 0.0 when the tip of the thumb and index finger are apart
+and 1.0 when they are together.
+
+Note that in this profile the ``aim pose`` is redefined as a pose between thumb
+and index finger, oriented so a ray cast can be used to identify a target.
+
+Grasp support is exposed through the ``squeeze`` input, the value of which
+is 0.0 when the hand is open, and 1.0 when a fist is made. 
+
+With this setup the normal ``left_hand`` and ``right_hand`` trackers are used and you can
+thus seamlessly switch between controller and hand tracking input.
+
+HTC hand interaction profile
+^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
+
+The `HTC hand interaction profile extension <https://github.khronos.org/OpenXR-Inventory/extension_support.html#XR_HTC_hand_interaction>`_
+was introduced by HTC and is defined similarly to the Microsoft extension.
+It is only supported by HTC for the Focus 3 and Elite XR headsets.
+
+.. image:: img/openxr_htc_hand_interaction_profile.webp
+
+See the Microsoft hand interaction profile for the gesture support.
+
+The defining difference is that this extension introduces two new trackers,
+``/user/hand_htc/left`` and ``/user/hand_htc/right``.
+This means that extra logic needs to be implemented to switch between the default trackers
+and the HTC specific trackers when the user puts down, or picks up, their controller.
+
+Simple controller profile
+^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
+
+The simple controller profile is a standard core profile defined as a fallback profile
+when a controller is used for which no profile exists.
+
+There are a number of OpenXR runtimes that will mimic controllers through
+the simple controller profile when hand tracking is used.
+
+Unfortunately there is no sound way to determine whether an unknown controller is used
+or whether hand tracking is emulating a controller through this profile.
+
+.. image:: img/openxr_simple_controller_hand.webp
+
+XR runtimes are free to define how the simple controller profile operates,
+so there is also no certainty to how this profile is mapped to gestures.
+
+The most common mapping seems to be that ``select click`` is true
+when the tip of the thumb and index fingers are touching while the
+user's palm is facing away from the user.
+``menu click`` will be true when tip of the thumb and index fingers
+are touching while the user's palm is facing towards the user.
+
+With this setup the normal ``left_hand`` and ``right_hand`` trackers are used and you can
+thus seamlessly switch between controller and hand tracking input.
+
+.. note::
 
-These are exposed through the following trackers:
+    As some of these interaction profiles have overlap it is important to know
+    that you can add each profile to your action map and the XR runtime will choose
+    the best fitting profile.
 
-.. list-table:: HTC trackers
-  :widths: 100
-  :header-rows: 0
+    For instance, a Meta Quest supports both the Microsoft hand interaction profile
+    and simple controller profile.
+    If both are specified the Microsoft hand interaction profile will take precedence
+    and will be used.
 
-  * - /user/vive_tracker_htcx/role/handheld_object
-  * - /user/vive_tracker_htcx/role/left_foot
-  * - /user/vive_tracker_htcx/role/right_foot
-  * - /user/vive_tracker_htcx/role/left_shoulder
-  * - /user/vive_tracker_htcx/role/right_shoulder
-  * - /user/vive_tracker_htcx/role/left_elbow
-  * - /user/vive_tracker_htcx/role/right_elbow
-  * - /user/vive_tracker_htcx/role/left_knee
-  * - /user/vive_tracker_htcx/role/right_knee
-  * - /user/vive_tracker_htcx/role/waist
-  * - /user/vive_tracker_htcx/role/chest
-  * - /user/vive_tracker_htcx/role/camera
-  * - /user/vive_tracker_htcx/role/keyboard
+    The expectation is that once Meta supports the core hand interaction profile
+    extension, that profile will take precedence over both Microsoft
+    and simple controller profiles.
 
+Gesture based input
+^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
 
-Some final words
-----------------
+If the platform doesn't support any interaction profiles when hand tracking is used,
+or if you're building an application where you need more complicated gesture support
+you're going to need to build your own gesture recognition system.
 
-Hand tracking is an area that is still under active development and we are expecting improvements in the near future.
+You can obtain the full hand tracking data through the :ref:`XRHandTracker <class_xrhandtracker>`
+resource for each hand. You can obtain the hand tracker by calling ``XRServer.get_tracker``
+and using either ``/user/hand_tracker/left`` or ``/user/hand_tracker/left`` as the tracker.
+This resource provides access to all the joint information for the given hand.
 
-The underlying principle that we're hoping will eventuate is that the action map will be used to handle interactions,
-while the hand tracking extension will primarily be a means for visualising the players hand.
-The hope here is that improvements to the OpenXR specification will ensure better portability between platforms.
+Detailing out a full gesture recognition algorithm goes beyond the scope of this manual
+however there are a number of community projects you can look at:
 
+ *  `Julian Todd's Auto hands library <https://github.com/Godot-Dojo/Godot-XR-AH>`_
+ *  `Malcolm Nixons Hand Pose Detector <https://github.com/Malcolmnixon/GodotXRHandPoseDetector>`_